Gift-Worthy Eyebrow Gels: 12 Picks for Cry Baby Girlies Who Need Brows to Last

Laura Sep 06 • 16 min read

Eyebrow gels are the unsung heroes of makeup routines. They tame, shape, and hold your brows in place, offering everything from light to strongholds depending on your needs. Whether you're after a natural look or something more dramatic, these gels are perfect gift ideas for your favorite "cry baby girlies"—those who love to express themselves through makeup but need a little extra staying power, especially during emotional moments.

Here’s a breakdown of the 12 best eyebrow-hold gels, covering everything from budget-friendly finds to luxurious splurges. We’ll cover key features, prices, and packaging so you can decide which one is best for you or a special person in your life.

1. Anastasia Beverly Hills Strong Hold Clear Brow Gel - $22

Features:
Anastasia Beverly Hills is known for iconic brow products, and this strong-hold clear brow gel is no exception. It locks brows into place with its long-lasting, all-day wear formula, ensuring they stay flawless from morning to night. It dries clear, making it suitable for all brow colors and types. The large wand makes application easy and efficient, giving you fuller and more defined brows in one quick sweep.

Price: $22
Packaging: The gel comes in 0.64 oz packaging, which provides plenty of product to last for months even with daily use.

Check out other available hot promo coupons at Anastasia Beverly Hills >>>> HERE <<<<

2. e.l.f. Clear Brow & Lash Mascara - $3

Features:
Looking for a budget-friendly option that doesn’t skimp on performance? e.l.f.’s Clear Brow & Lash Mascara is the ideal pick. This multitasking product can be used on both brows and lashes, perfect for minimalists who prefer a streamlined makeup routine. Its lightweight and airy texture ensures that it sets the brows without making them feel crunchy or stiff.

Price: $3
Packaging: The 0.08 oz dual-ended packaging separates the brow gel from the lash product, making it easy to switch between the two functions.

Check out other available hot promo coupons at E.l.f. Cosmetics >>>> HERE <<<<

3. Kimiko The Brow Sensei - $35

Features:
Kimiko’s The Brow Sensei is a luxury eyebrow gel that offers more than hold—it nourishes your brows with a conditioning formula enriched with peptides and amino acids. This not only keeps your brows in place but also helps them grow stronger and healthier. The lightweight gel dries clear, providing a natural look while still taming even the most unruly hairs.

Price: $35
Packaging: The 0.07 oz packaging is compact and sleek, ideal for tossing in your purse for on-the-go touch-ups.

Check out other available hot promo coupons at Kimiko Beauty >>>> HERE <<<<

4. NYX Professional Makeup The Brow Glue - $8

Features:
This affordable option from NYX delivers a strong hold without feeling sticky, which is often a concern with brow gels. The formula is flexible, allowing for some movement without losing its hold. Its only drawback is the small wand, which might require a few extra passes to cover the entire brow evenly.

Price: $8
Packaging: The gel comes in a small 0.18 oz tube, perfect for travel or those who prefer to use less product.

Check out other available hot promo coupons at NYX Cosmetics >>>> HERE <<<<

5. Kosas Brow Fluff & Hold Treatment Gel - $24

Features:
Kosas combines brow care and makeup with its Brow Fluff & Hold Treatment Gel. The mini spoolie brush tapers at the end, allowing you to shape and define your brows with precision. The creamy formula doesn’t flake and feels comfortable on the skin, making it a great option for anyone who wants soft, full brows that stay put all day.

Price: $24
Packaging: This gel comes in a 0.13 oz package, making it compact yet lasting for several months with regular use.

Check out other available hot promo coupons at Kosas Cosmetics >>>> HERE <<<<

6. MAC Brow Set - $25

Features:
MAC’s Brow Set is designed for those who need their brows to stay in place all day. The gel provides a firm hold while maintaining the flexibility of the hairs. However, the long wand may pick up too much product at once, so you may need to scrape some off before applying to avoid a heavy look.

Price: $25
Packaging: The 0.28 oz packaging offers a substantial amount of product, though be cautious with the wand to avoid product buildup.

Check out other available hot promo coupons at MAC Cosmetics >>>> HERE <<<<

7. Ami Colé Brow Shaping Gel - $20

Features:
This brow gel from Ami Colé, a Black-owned beauty brand, offers a light to medium hold with a nourishing formula that conditions your brows. It’s perfect for those who want a more natural look, as it doesn’t provide an overly stiff hold. It’s designed to enhance the natural shape and texture of your brows while keeping them groomed.

Price: $20
Packaging: It comes in a 0.17 oz tube, making it easy to carry in your makeup bag for touch-ups throughout the day.

8. Maybelline Great Lash Clear Mascara - $13

Features:
One of the most iconic drugstore products, Maybelline’s Great Lash Clear Mascara is a multitasking wonder that can be used on both brows and lashes. It provides a flexible hold for your brows, though the gel itself has a cold and wet texture, which might take some time to get used to. It’s best for those who want a natural, not overly structured brow look.

Price: $13
Packaging: This clear brow and lash gel comes in a 0.44 oz tube, giving you a significant amount of product for the price.

Check out other available hot promo coupons at Maybelline >>>> HERE <<<<

9. Makeup By Mario Master Hold Brow Gel - $37

Features:
For those who need serious brow-holding power, Makeup By Mario’s Master Hold Brow Gel is the answer. It offers an ultra-strong hold that will keep your brows in place through anything, but it does result in a somewhat stiff finish. Despite the small 0.1 oz packaging, a little goes a long way, so it lasts for quite a while.

Price: $37
Packaging: The compact 0.1 oz tube is sleek and easy to carry, but the higher price tag reflects its luxury status.

Check out other available hot promo coupons at Makeup By Mario >>>> HERE <<<<

10. Joey Healy Brow Structure Clear Set - $25

Features:
Joey Healy’s Brow Structure Clear Set is a lightweight, flake-free gel that holds your brows without feeling heavy. It’s particularly effective at shaping and defining your brows, and its clear formula ensures that it works for all brow colors. This is a great option for those who want a strong hold without the stiff, sticky feeling that some gels leave behind.

Price: $25
Packaging: The gel comes in a 0.25 oz tube, which is larger than many other options and will last for a long time with regular use.

Check out other available hot promo coupons at Joey Healy >>>> HERE <<<<

11. W3ll People Expressionist Clear Brow Gel - $13

Features:
For those looking for a more natural, eco-friendly option, W3ll People’s Expressionist Clear Brow Gel is infused with nourishing ingredients like aloe and olive oil. While it provides only a light hold, it’s perfect for people who want to maintain a soft, flexible brow look while conditioning their brow hairs.

Price: $13
Packaging: The 0.24 oz tube is slightly larger than most, making it a good value for its price point, especially given its nourishing formula.

Check out other available hot promo coupons at W3ll People >>>> HERE <<<<

12. Hourglass Arch Brow Shaping Gel - $29

Features:
Hourglass offers a clear brow gel that focuses on creating a natural-looking finish. Its specialty brush is designed to coat and shape brows evenly without making them look overdone. However, it only provides a light hold, so it’s best for those who prefer a more subtle, polished look rather than a heavily structured brow.

Price: $29
Packaging: The 0.1 oz packaging is on the smaller side, but the brush design and lightweight formula make it an excellent choice for precise application.

Check out other available hot promo coupons at Hourglass Cosmetics >>>> HERE <<<<

Final Thoughts

When choosing the best eyebrow gel, it’s important to consider the level of hold, the texture of the formula, and how it fits into your makeup routine. For crybaby girlies who need something to keep their brows in place through thick and thin (literally), options like Anastasia Beverly Hills Strong Hold Clear Brow Gel and Makeup By Mario Master Hold Brow Gel are perfect for all-day, heavy-duty wear.

On the other hand, if you prefer a more natural look with conditioning benefits, products like Kimiko The Brow Sensei and W3ll People Expressionist Clear Brow Gel offer lightweight hold with nourishing ingredients.

With a range of prices from budget-friendly to high-end, there’s something for everyone, no matter their brow goals. Whether it’s a practical stocking stuffer or a luxurious splurge, these gels are sure to make your brows—and your day—look effortlessly polished.